Banks warn UK Treasury of risk of sector turmoil after car finance ruling

Unlock the Editor’s Digest for free

Roula Khalaf, Editor of the FT, selects her favourite stories in this weekly newsletter.

Lenders have held urgent talks with the UK Treasury and the main financial watchdog over the risk of turmoil in the consumer credit sector, days after a court ruling against car finance commissions that threatens to disrupt swaths of business activity.

The meeting on Tuesday between finance bosses, government officials and regulators underlined anxiety in the motor finance industry about a Court of Appeal decision last week, in which senior judges ruled in favour of consumers who complained about “secret” commissions on car loans.

Certain commissions that lenders paid to car dealerships for arranging loans were unlawful, the judges found, prompting lawyers to warn that the industry could face a costly customer redress scheme.

The uncertainty sparked by Friday’s ruling prompted the Finance and Leasing Association (FLA), which represents many consumer loan companies, to attend an urgent meeting with officials from the Treasury and the Financial Conduct Authority.

One person familiar with the talks said FLA representatives warned officials of the wide-ranging impact of the judgment, which meant large businesses were “effectively” not up to scratch with the law and therefore had to rush to change their systems.

Lawyers said the judgment was an overwhelming defeat for the industry and could leave other areas of finance exposed to legal challenges. It prompted analysts to raise their forecasts of the likely cost of compensation faced by car finance companies, which they already estimated could cost the sector as much as £16bn.

Stephen Haddrill, FLA director-general, said after the ruling that it was “significant” and had implications “which stretch far beyond the motor finance sector, making it an issue that demands the immediate attention of the FCA”.

The ruling could have implications for a range of lending activities involving the payment of hidden commissions by consumer finance providers to brokers, according to the trade body and legal experts.

It prompted FTSE 250 lender Close Brothers to pause all motor finance lending. The bank, which has the highest relative exposure to car finance of any lender, has already lost more than half its market value since regulators first announced in January they were investigating the sector. 

Lloyds Banking Group, which owns Black Horse, Britain’s largest car finance business, said the ruling set “a higher bar” for the disclosure of and consent to commissions than had been “understood to be required or applied across the motor finance industry prior to the decision”.

The FTSE 100 company said it was “assessing the potential impact of the decisions, as well as any broader implications, pending the outcome of the appeal applications”. And Spanish bank Santander delayed publication of its full UK results as it sought to quantify the impact of Friday’s judgment.

In addition to Close Brothers, the ruling sided with consumers against FirstRand. The South African lender said the decision had “far-reaching and materially negative implications for the motor finance industry and broader consumer finance sectors in the UK”.

The FCA opened a probe into potential mis-selling of car finance this year and will update the market on its next steps in May.

Lawyers and analysts have said Friday’s ruling makes it more likely the watchdog will implement a costly redress scheme for lenders, mirroring remediation imposed over the payment protection insurance (PPI) scandal that ended up costing the banking sector almost £50bn.

The FCA said last month it was extending until December the pause it imposed this year on compensation claims by customers seeking redress on car financing costs, in order to allow time for various court rulings that are expected to shape the outcome of its investigation.

Barclays is appealing against a ruling by the Financial Ombudsman Service, which handles complaints made by consumers against financial services companies, that granted a customer redress for car financing provided by the bank. Close Brothers and First Rand have both said they will appeal against Friday’s judgment.

The FLA, the FCA and the Treasury did not immediately respond to requests for comment.